Unlock the Editor’s Digest free of charge
Payment compression could lastly be reaching the profitable indexing trade with world revenues rising much less quickly than fund trade property final 12 months.
Worldwide revenues for the more and more influential index suppliers rose 9.3 per cent to a report $5.8bn final 12 months, in keeping with estimates from Burton Taylor Worldwide Consulting, a analysis and advisory group targeted on capital markets.
Nonetheless, this was comfortably beneath final 12 months’s 15.5 per cent rise within the property of open-ended and change traded funds (excluding cash market funds) globally, in keeping with figures from Morningstar Direct.
The drop in index income in relation to fund property represents a break from latest years, with world index revenues having risen at a five-year compound annual progress fee of 11 per cent, in keeping with Burton Taylor, sooner than the 8.5 per cent five-year CAGR of funding property, based mostly on Morningstar knowledge, even bearing in mind 2023.
Asset managers have lengthy complained that index suppliers are taking an ever-larger slice of the income pie. Whereas fund administration charges have fallen precipitously in recent times, notably for passive index-tracking ETFs, the sums asset managers in flip pay to index suppliers haven’t fallen wherever close to as quick, if in any respect.
Funds usually pay an annual price equal to about a few foundation factors of property to an index supplier for the fitting to trace or benchmark in opposition to a proprietary index. Alternatively their mother or father firms will pay flat-rate subscription charges for entry to a bundle of indices and different companies.
Because of this combined fee mannequin, progress in index charges is more likely to undershoot progress in property throughout years when markets rally strongly. Nonetheless, Brad Bailey, analysis director at Burton Taylor, believed index charges have been genuinely beginning to fall.
“There was appreciable value strain. We’re seeing competitors within the index enterprise by way of charges. These charges actually should go down,” stated Bailey, who believed funding financial institution and hedge fund teams have been rising as rivals to the inventory exchanges and specialised index suppliers which have historically dominated the trade.
“The economics are shifting” with “rising index revenues bringing newer suppliers to the desk, pressuring charges downwards”, Bailey added.
Specifically, smaller index suppliers providing “extra enticing pricing” have prompted asset managers to “rethink their earlier aversion to lesser-known suppliers”, he stated.
Extra broadly, “the index enterprise has simply exploded”, Bailey added, with asset managers launching a panoply of thematic and environmental, social and governance-based funds that require ever extra particular indices.
Bailey added that the motion of indices to areas reminiscent of non-public fairness, actual property and credit score have been additionally offering recent sources of income for indexers.
Regardless of the expansion of some smaller suppliers, simply three teams — MSCI, S&P Dow Jones Indices and FTSE Russell — accounted for 70.3 per cent of index charges final 12 months, in keeping with Burton Taylor.
MSCI overtook S&P to assert prime spot in 2023, with notably sturdy progress in its ESG indices pushing total revenues 11.4 per cent larger to $1.5bn.
Nasdaq, the fourth-largest participant, has seen revenues rise at five-year CAGR of 20.7 per cent, taking its market share to 9.1 per cent final 12 months, aided by rising urge for food for lots of the shares listed on its tech-heavy change, headed by the so-called Magnificent Seven.
Amongst smaller gamers, Morningstar’s five-year CAGR is 34 per cent, taking its market share to 1.1 per cent, helped by its acquisition of ESG specialist Sustainalytics in 2020. Morningstar’s ESG-related revenues surged 133 per cent final 12 months, in keeping with Burton Taylor’s numbers.
Germany’s Solactive, which gives “a disruptive pricing mannequin charging shoppers a flat price”, in keeping with Bailey, has chalked up a 20.8 per cent five-year CAGR, with its market share additionally now 1.1 per cent.
People who have misplaced market share over the previous 5 years, whereas nonetheless seeing rises in nominal revenues, embrace Deutsche Börse’s ISS Stoxx, which operates the Euro Stoxx and Dax households of indices; Alerian, finest recognized for its grasp restricted partnership index; and Bloomberg, which nonetheless stays primary for mounted earnings indices, narrowly forward of FTSE Russell for this class.