Keep knowledgeable with free updates
When Liontrust is ejected from the FTSE 250 this month, it can cap a 12 months by which the UK asset supervisor has suffered billions in outflows, tried a doomed bid for Swiss rival GAM and shed half its market worth.
The London-based cash supervisor was as soon as a darling of the sector, with chief government John Ions presiding over a rise in belongings from £1bn to £36bn within the decade to September 2021.
Then, Ions put the corporate’s success all the way down to having the proper merchandise, listening to shoppers, and “momentum”, with the group benefiting from a decade of rising fairness markets and later households’ pandemic-era financial savings.
However shares within the £27bn UK asset supervisor have misplaced four-fifths of their worth since their peak in August 2021, and belongings have dropped by 1 / 4.
A part of the ache has been sector-wide, with midsized managers discovering themselves squeezed between juggernauts, reminiscent of BlackRock and Vanguard, and specialist managers, reminiscent of Baillie Gifford. The flight to passive funds has compounded stress to chop charges similtaneously regulatory prices have been rising.
“You’ve got to be a trillion greenback supervisor providing a number of issues, or it’s important to be a very effectively run specialist,” mentioned one former companion at Liontrust. “The center of the highway [firms] are all struggling.”
Liontrust declined to remark for this text.
Based in 1995, Liontrust made its identify as a boutique UK equities progress home. Since Ions was named chief government in 2010, he has launched into an acquisition spree, shopping for seven corporations in 12 years as a part of a push to diversify the fund home.
However that effort has had blended outcomes. The acquisition of Alliance Belief Investments in 2017 is broadly seen as a hit, bringing sustainable investing experience to Liontrust simply because the theme discovered favour with traders.
Different offers are nonetheless to repay. Acquisitions of Neptune Funding Administration in 2019 and Architas in 2020 have but to generate gross income above their prices. The 2022 acquisition of equities boutique Majedie for £120mn, was an “unmitigated catastrophe”, mentioned Robert Sage, analyst at Peel Hunt.
Property at Majedie’s Tortoise fund plummeted from £712mn in Might to £10mn in August after its two managers left. The supervisor of one other Majedie fund, the £1.2bn Edinburgh Funding Belief, introduced his retirement in October.
Ions’ newest tried deal was a £96mn bid for struggling asset supervisor GAM, introduced in Might, which he declared would “create a worldwide asset supervisor, well-positioned for long-term progress”.
However GAM shareholders have been unmoved. The bid was derailed by activist group NewGAMe and finally solely one-third of GAM shareholders backed the takeover in August. Liontrust was pressured to retreat.
One prime 10 shareholder in Liontrust mentioned the board misjudged how the market would react to the proposed deal, saying that the advantages of the tie-up have been by no means “crystal clear”. “It’s already a tricky atmosphere and also you’re doing one thing that individuals aren’t leaping at,” the investor mentioned.
This had been the “hardest interval” of Ions tenure, mentioned the chief government of a rival asset supervisor, and the collapse of the GAM deal “doesn’t make it straightforward for [him]”.
Traders have within the meantime pulled a web quantity of £3.2bn from Liontrust funds over the six months to the top of September, on prime of £4.8bn redeemed within the 12 months to March. Market strikes and funding efficiency have pushed belongings down an additional £3bn over the 18 months to the top of September.
Regardless of Ions’ enlargement technique, the asset supervisor’s most important focus has remained UK equities, that are deeply unloved by traders. Traders have pulled £10.6bn from UK shares up to now this 12 months.
Ions “misplaced some credibility” because of the botched GAM deal, mentioned one analyst. Liontrust’s board has additionally are available for scrutiny, even earlier than the failed GAM bid.
In March, a row erupted over the 12-year tenure of Alastair Barbour, who has served as chair for the previous 4 years. Company governance finest apply restricts board members to nine-year phrases. Fellow board members Emma Howard Boyd and Quintin Value resigned, and on the AGM in September, 15 per cent of shareholders voted towards Barbour’s re-election. Barbour stays within the put up.
One prime 25 shareholder instructed the Monetary Instances that Liontrust’s shares look low cost following the sell-off. “A few of the funds and the fund managers there are robust and have robust monitor data, and that’s what we’re backing,” he mentioned.
However the large threat of fund supervisor departure remained, mentioned the previous companion on the firm. Liontrust had some “wonderful” fund managers, he mentioned. “[But] in the event that they stroll out of the door there’s nothing left.”