This text is an on-site model of our Ethical Cash e-newsletter. Enroll here to get the e-newsletter despatched straight to your inbox.
Go to our Ethical Cash hub for all the newest ESG information, opinion and evaluation from across the FT
Welcome again. Up to now, strain on banks over their fossil gas publicity has targeted totally on oil, gasoline and the thermal coal utilized in energy vegetation.
Metallurgical coal, and the blast furnaces that burn it as a part of the steelmaking course of, has been much less within the highlight — regardless of its massive contribution to local weather change. However as low-carbon know-how progresses, some monetary establishments are turning their again on conventional steelmaking. Learn on for extra.
Decarbonisation
Are we on the correct path to fulfill inexperienced metal targets?
At first look, final week’s announcement by Tata Metal on its UK operations may appear like a mirrored image of the inexorable inexperienced transformation of heavy trade. The Indian firm is to shut its coal-burning blast furnaces within the Welsh city of Port Talbot — which is able to include the lack of 2,800 jobs — and substitute them with far much less carbon-intensive electrical arc furnaces.
Extra warning indicators for metal’s conventional enterprise mannequin have been coming from the monetary sector. Final month, Dutch financial institution ING stated it could now not finance new mines producing the metallurgical coal utilized in blast furnaces, following comparable bulletins from European friends together with HSBC and Lloyds Banking Group.
But on the world stage, the outlook for metal’s inexperienced transition appears to be like decidedly combined. Information printed final 12 months by International Power Monitor confirmed that 138 metallurgical coal mines had been being deliberate worldwide, together with 160 new blast furnaces so as to add to the 1,023 already working.
Steelmaking accounts for about 7 per cent of worldwide greenhouse gasoline emissions. With world metal demand set to continue to grow — by greater than a 3rd from 2020 ranges by 2050, based on the Worldwide Power Company — this trade must speed up a inexperienced shift. And if that shift is to occur, the monetary sector might want to play an enormous function.
In 2015, ING turned one of many first banks to announce a coverage towards financing mines producing thermal coal utilized in energy vegetation. In 2022, it stated it could now not help the event of latest oil and gasoline manufacturing fields.
It had held again from making an identical announcement on metallurgical coal due to concern about whether or not there was a sensible various pathway for the trade, stated Arnaud Cohen Stuart, ING’s head of enterprise ethics. The brand new restriction introduced final month, he stated, was in response to some “actually, actually fascinating” developments in low-carbon metal know-how.
Some of the vital of these is the Hybrit inexperienced metal undertaking in northern Sweden, which I visited final 12 months for our Moral Money film on the hydrogen economy. A three way partnership between steelmaker SSAB, iron ore producer LKAB and power firm Vattenfall, it makes use of hydrogen, as an alternative of coal, to drag the oxygen out of iron ore — giving off water vapour instead of carbon dioxide. The hydrogen is produced by way of electrolysis, utilizing Sweden’s plentiful hydroelectric and wind energy.
Even with this low-cost renewable power, SSAB says the manufacturing price of its inexperienced metal is about 30 per cent greater than the standard equal. In order Europe tries to construct a number one function in inexperienced metal manufacturing, governments are deploying beneficiant subsidies to get issues shifting.
Thyssenkrupp has been awarded €2bn by the German authorities to help its hydrogen-based funding plans, whereas ArcelorMittal in 2023 was promised a complete of €1.2bn by varied European governments for its decarbonisation plans.
Ephrem Ravi, an analyst at Citi, informed me {that a} a lot greater worth for EU carbon permits can be wanted to shut the associated fee hole on inexperienced metal manufacturing and remove the necessity for subsidies. Even then, he famous, to transform all Europe’s major (that means non-recycled) metal manufacturing to the inexperienced hydrogen-based course of would require an unlimited quantity of latest renewable power: roughly the identical because the UK’s complete electrical energy capability from all sources.
To guard its heavy trade towards carbon-intensive international rivals, the EU is introducing an efficient carbon tax on imports of metal and different merchandise. EU officers are hoping that this might speed up decarbonisation in different nations, as corporations search to guard gross sales in Europe. However Ravi warned that the influence can be restricted by the comparatively modest demand for metal within the EU’s mature economic system. “Europe, frankly, shouldn’t overestimate its significance within the world metal market,” Ravi stated.
The EU and UK collectively used 152mn tonnes of completed metal merchandise in 2022, based on the World Metal Affiliation. In the meantime, China used 921mn tonnes — greater than the remainder of the world mixed.
However whereas China’s authorities has not matched the eye-catching European subsidy bulletins for hydrogen-based inexperienced metal, its state-owned steelmakers have been investing rising sums in decarbonisation — particularly by transitioning to electrical arc furnaces, which principally use recycled scrap metal.
The availability of used metal is ready to rise strongly within the subsequent couple of a long time, with the scrapping of buildings and infrastructure from China’s early twenty first century funding surge. Coupled with slowing demand progress, that can feed a gradual development within the trade in direction of recycled metal, say Chathu Gamage and Thomas Koch Clean, analysts on the Rocky Mountain Institute.
Major metal manufacturing from iron ore will more and more occur with out the usage of coal, Gamage and Clean add, as inexperienced metal know-how advances and more durable carbon pricing regimes kick in. Particularly, they be aware, iron ore miners in sun-soaked Western Australia have enormous alternatives to course of their output close to the purpose of extraction utilizing inexperienced hydrogen.
All this, they argue, signifies that it appears to be like borderline reckless — even leaving apart local weather issues — to make long-term monetary commitments to blast furnaces or metallurgical coal mines. Knowledgeable buyers ought to now be contemplating, Clean says, whether or not such belongings could possibly be left “stranded” with out prospects within the years forward.
Good learn
Susannah Savage’s Huge Learn, which printed yesterday, is a vital examine a fraught matter: decarbonisation efforts in agriculture. Huge meals corporations are touting regenerative agriculture as a approach to reduce greenhouse gasoline emissions, however in apply there are important hurdles.