Unlock the Editor’s Digest totally free
It’s no secret that Gulf autocrats management severe cheddar. A (paywalled) report out this month makes an attempt to estimate fairly how a lot.
Totting up the obtainable numbers, World SWF reckon the Gulf Cooperation Council’s ruling households management round $6.8 trillion of belongings. That’s two complete Apples! Click on by way of the chart under to see how this breaks down by state, class and fund:
What do these funds even do with $6.8 trillion? It seems, a minimum of 4 issues.
First, they diversify their economies past the anticipated lifetime of the reservoir of hydrocarbons upon which the area floats.
Second, they project soft power internationally. Suppose soccer, golf, media, universities, possibly even the seize of worldwide skilled elites by way of butlering gigs.
Third, buy garish bling and stroke rulers’ giant egos.
Lastly, they personal just about the whole lot in touching distance. In response to the report, Gulf SWFs personal each one in all their nationwide champions throughout each main trade. State capitalism at its most evident (high-res here):
Nevertheless it’s not simply champions. Additionally they personal most of all shares listed in GCC.
The report’s authors combed by way of the share registers of every of the 877 corporations listed within the area and located that 68 per cent of the Abu Dhabi market cap is owned by native SWFs and royal household workplaces. In Saudi, a full 77 per cent of the market is owned by PIF and the state. For the GCC total, 70 per cent of market capitalisation is in the end state-owned.
Admittedly, a lot of that is owing to the outsized prominence of the Saudi market within the area, and the outsized prominence of the just about wholly state-owned Aramco. However nonetheless:
Dangle on, is that this an opportunity for one more marimekko second?!
Regardless of proudly owning a lot of their listed markets, GCC authorities have nonetheless made some efforts to get outsiders involved in their shares. These efforts have had combined outcomes.
Norway’s $1.7 trillion mega-SWF NBIM divested all its Saudi shares in 2021. And Norway’s largest home pension fund KLP dumped GCC stocks on human rights considerations in 2023. Sweden’s large pension fund AP7 blacklisted Saudi Aramco — which makes up round 1 / 4 of the area’s market cap — in the beginning of the 12 months, though this didn’t cease Saudi from promoting $11.2bn of inventory over the summer season, albeit on the backside finish of the vary and at a 6 per cent low cost to the market. And regardless of its phenomenal share worth progress, IHC (which constitutes round a 3rd of Abu Dhabi’s ADX alternate market cap) largely simply perplexes worldwide traders.
However passive traders? They’re way more enthused. Or, a minimum of, they’ve discovered their cash poured into the area following selections made by the index suppliers to whom they’ve outsourced funding decision-making. MSCI’s resolution to incorporate UAE and Qatar (in 2014), Saudi (in 2019), and Kuwait (in 2020) to its indices has meant anybody committing money to a MSCI EM or MSCI ACWI tracker fund is shopping for shares within the area.
The BIS noted that MSCI and FTSE’s admission of Saudi shares to their indices in 2019 coincided with overseas fairness flows into the nation that exceeded these heading to India and China. And MSCI themselves calculate that overseas funding in Saudi shares has more than quadrupled from $23.5bn to $97.5bn since their index inclusion resolution was made.
Considerably unusually, the examine consists of Royal Personal Workplaces — a class of state-controlled belongings we haven’t seen analysed earlier than. These account for a cool $0.5tn, or about half a Berkshire Hathaway, which sounds possibly much less spectacular. Virtually $350bnof these belongings are run for the UAE’s ruling Al Nahyan family alone. However because the authors word:
This group of entities, led by Abu Dhabi’s Royal Group and all its subsidiaries, is much more opaque than SWFs … hyperlinks to the royal households could make the boundaries between SWFs and RPOs blurry at instances.
Provided that GCC states are overwhelmingly absolute monarchies, it’s most likely not price getting too hung up over the excellence.