This text is an on-site model of our Ethical Cash publication. Premium subscribers can join here to get the publication delivered 3 times per week. Commonplace subscribers can improve to Premium right here, or discover all FT newsletters.
Go to our Ethical Cash hub for all the newest ESG information, opinion and evaluation from across the FT
Florida residents are reeling at this time from the influence of Hurricane Milton, which tore by coastal communities, killing no less than 10 individuals and leaving greater than 3mn with out energy.
The catastrophe got here simply two weeks after the devastation of Hurricane Helene, which killed greater than 225 individuals in North Carolina and different southern US states. It’s highlighted the grave threat to individuals and property posed by excessive climate occasions — a menace that, local weather scientists warn, is being exacerbated by local weather change.
And as we spotlight in at this time’s publication, institutional buyers are paying elevated consideration to this topic — serving to to drive income development for a world monetary knowledge large.
capital markets
MSCI’s ESG and local weather enterprise development charge has peaked. What’s subsequent?
Over the previous quarter-century, Henry Fernandez has constructed MSCI into one of many world’s largest monetary knowledge and index suppliers by an obsessive concentrate on what’s drawing the eye of world buyers.
Fernandez took cost of the enterprise, then a division of the funding financial institution Morgan Stanley, in 1998, and oversaw its spin-out as an unbiased firm in 2007. Now with a market capitalisation of $46.5bn, it’s greatest recognized for the market index merchandise it compiles, which nonetheless present the lion’s share of its income.
Throughout a lot of the previous 5 years, nevertheless, its fastest-growing enterprise has been offering rankings and metrics round environmental, social and governance threat. That development has slowed extra lately, Fernandez instructed me once we met in New York throughout Local weather Week NYC. Nevertheless it’s nonetheless increasing at a good clip — now pushed, he stated, largely by buyers’ rising concern about excessive climate.
Within the first quarter of 2022, the year-on-year development charge in working revenues for MSCI’s ESG and local weather enterprise peaked at 50 per cent. Within the second quarter of this yr, that charge was 13 per cent — far under the long-term development goal of “mid to excessive 20s” that MSCI has set for this division (these figures seek advice from natural development, excluding the influence of acquisitions, asset disposals and foreign money fluctuations).
“For certain, our charge of development for local weather instruments has slowed down,” Fernandez stated. “That’s a serious deceleration.”
The slowing development in demand for these instruments would possibly reinforce suspicions that monetary buyers are slacking off within the consideration they pay to local weather and sustainability points, after a peak in enthusiasm roughly three years in the past.
However the 13 per cent development charge for ESG and local weather instruments outstripped MSCI’s general natural improve in working revenues within the second quarter, which was 10 per cent. Which means this unit has continued to develop as a proportion of MSCI’s broader enterprise. ESG and local weather instruments accounted for 11.2 per cent of MSCI’s $708mn income within the second quarter of this yr, up from 7.9 per cent three years earlier.
MSCI’s rivals within the house are additionally experiencing continued development in demand for some of these knowledge. S&P World stated its income from sustainability and vitality transition-related companies grew 24 per cent to $301mn final yr. The London Inventory Alternate Group stated in its newest earnings replace that its FTSE Russell subsidiary’s “concentrate on local weather transition is including to development”, although it didn’t present detailed figures.
However Fernandez highlighted an fascinating shift in investor focus. He’s seeing a specific slowdown in demand development for transition-related instruments and knowledge — that’s, associated to firms’ carbon emissions and different metrics that present their dangers across the world transfer to cleaner vitality. As an alternative, Fernandez stated the stability of demand was shifting in direction of instruments that assist buyers to gauge and handle bodily dangers — for instance, round their belongings’ publicity to hurricanes, droughts or floods.
As south-eastern US falls beneath the newest of a brutal sequence of hurricanes, this consideration appears nicely merited. Final yr was the fourth consecutive yr during which insured losses topped $100bn, as US house insurers suffered their worst internet underwriting loss this century. A latest report from analysts at Verisk warned that insurers ought to anticipate to cowl annual losses of greater than $150bn within the years to come back.
Unsurprisingly, Fernandez stated a lot of the demand for MSCI’s bodily threat merchandise was coming from insurance coverage firms, which should handle dangers of their huge funding portfolios in addition to within the insurance policies they provide to houses and companies. However banks have been additionally exhibiting rising curiosity in these merchandise, he stated. And so too are buyers in non-public markets — main Fernandez to hope for some helpful dovetailing between two of the fastest-growing components of his firm.
Fernandez has been increasing MSCI’s enterprise in offering instruments for the more and more buzzy non-public markets house, from actual property and infrastructure to the booming non-public credit score funds which can be consuming into banks’ industrial lending enterprise. Final yr MSCI paid $697mn to accumulate Burgiss, a personal belongings knowledge and analytics supplier. This drove a soar within the contribution of MSCI’s non-public belongings division to group revenues, which reached 9 per cent within the second quarter of this yr.
To date, Fernandez identified, a lot evaluation of ESG and local weather dangers has targeted on publicly traded securities — partly as a result of it’s typically simpler to entry knowledge on them. However when large diversified buyers are trying on the threat of their portfolios, these belongings — given how simply they are often traded — might give much less pressing trigger for concern than illiquid bodily belongings in actual property and infrastructure, Fernandez prompt. “So individuals are starting to say: ‘Perhaps I ought to as an alternative of specializing in public equities, possibly I ought to concentrate on that bridge, possibly I ought to concentrate on that airport.’”
Good learn
The leaders of greater than 100 firms together with AstraZeneca, Nestlé and Hitachi have printed an open letter urging authorities motion on local weather change, forward of subsequent month’s COP29 summit in Baku.